By C. M. Surrisi on January 17, 2025
The Dilemma
Many authors who love middle grade mysteries would like to write one. Hurrah! We always welcome new mysteries. However, it is not uncommon in this endeavor to dive in with a clever idea and then at about page fifty, give up. Why? Because it’s darn hard for a kid to solve a mystery.
Why is that? To solve a crime, a sleuth needs the ability to take action that affects the investigation and outcome, or in a word: agency. The youth-sleuth has some inherent handicaps in this regard. So when writing the middle grade mystery, how do you deal with these obstacles, and what can you do to make the most of them?
Fortunately, there is an established model which appeared in the earliest middle grade mysteries (e.g., Emil and the Detectives, Nancy Drew, Trixie Belden) and endures in today’s kid-crime novels.
The model has three parts.
-
First, you should understand the kid-sleuth’s unique problems. For example:
- They usually can’t drive.
- They have curfews.
- They have parents watching over them.
- They have little or no money.
- They do/don’t carry phones.
- They lack life experience.
- They can disagree and bicker among themselves (true of adults, also!).
- They are told to stay out of the way.
- They are discredited when they offer advice and evidence.
- They are prone to misunderstand things they have no experience with and thus can misinterpret clues.
In other words, they’re kids.
-
Second, you need to create a story world where they can investigate successfully. For example:
- A location they can navigate, e.g., a boarding school, a small town, a camp, etc.
- A season that allows them access to the outdoors. This will vastly expand your opportunity for unique scenes.
- A lack of constant, immediate oversight. In other words, a single parent, working parent(s), deceased parent(s), no parent(s), inattentive oversight by teachers, camp counselors, etc.
- A knowledge of the law (however misguided) through TV, movies, parental jobs, the police station next door, etc.
-
Finally, turn their disadvantages into superpowers. For example, here are some ways to work around a few of the issues mentioned above:
- Set the book in a location such as a boarding school. This eliminates troublesome parental oversight. Check out: Murder Is Bad Manners by Robin Stevens https://robin-stevens.co.uk and The Scandalous Sisterhood of Prickwillow Place by Julie Berry. https://www.julieberrybooks.com
- Set the book in the past. This eliminates the pesky problem of smartphones and technology. Check out: One Came Home by Amy Timberlake. https://www.amytimberlake.com/one-came-home
- Give your character a sheriff for a mom. This can provide kids with lots of understanding and misunderstanding of the law. Check out: The Maypop Kidnapping by C. M. Surrisi. https://cmsurrisi.com
- Create a youth-sleuth who is insignificant to some adults. That makes kids the perfect young spies. Check Out: Enola Holmes: The Case of the Missing Marquess by Nancy Springer. https://www.nancyspringer.com
- Don’t forget that small people can hide in small spaces. Check out: The House of Dies Drear by Virginia Hamilton.https://www.virginiahamilton.com
- Remember that sleepovers are great investigative-planning sessions. Check out: Sleepover Stakeout (Sleuth or Dare #2) by Kim Harrington https://www.goodreads.com/series/67971-sleuth-or-dare and A Split Second by Janae Marks. https://www.janaemarks.com
- Include a smart kid with endless questions who may inadvertently get some good answers. Check out: Nosy Parker by Lesley Crewe https://www.lesleycrewe.com and The Sasquatch of Hawthorne Elementary by K. B. Jackson. https://kbjackson.com
- Consider that sometimes naïve or mistaken assumptions are the obvious answer. Check out: Theo Tan and the Fox Spirit by Jesse Q. Sutanto, https://jesseqsutantoauthor.com where kids misinterpret cultural clues and cryptic codes.
- Don’t forget that disabilities are not necessarily disabling when it comes to solving mysteries. Check out: Insignificant Events in the Life of a Cactus by Dusti Bowling. https://www.dustibowling.com/other-books-1
- And keep in mind that the middle school curse of stressed friendships sometimes helps in solving mysteries. Check out: The Wig in the Window by Kristen Kittscher. https://www.harpercollins.com/blogs/authors/kristen-kittscher-20151020751610
There you have some pointers on creating a successful middle grade sleuth. If you can think of items you would add to these lists, please add them to the comments below. Happy writing!
(c)cmsurrisi